Let’s take a look at a challenge many redheads face: finding the perfect eyebrow pencil. We all know that most brow products have traditionally catered to blondes, brunettes, and those with black hair. But redheads need their own unique shades to complement their stunning hair colors. Whether you’re a professional makeup artist or simply on the hunt for the ideal brow pencil for yourself, I’ve got you covered. Join me as I share my top nine picks of high-quality, long-lasting eyebrow pencils crafted specifically for red or auburn hair. Let’s get started!

best eyebrow pencils if you have red or auburn hair
woman sitting on brown surface

Listen to Episode:

Or Listen On:

.

This post may contain affiliate links, such as Amazon and Shop My, that I may earn from qualifying links. This means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my links, but never fear, because it means no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure for more information.

.

In This Episode We Cover:

  • Understanding that the perfect brow pencil for redheads doesn’t need to match a person’s hair color exactly, but should complement it, is essential.
  • Exploring both high-end options and budget-friendly picks will give you the freedom to choose products that suit your needs and wallet.
  • Numerous quality options available today for red and auburn hair, without compromising on performance or shade accuracy.

Episode 84: Show notes

woman sitting on brown surface

Finding the perfect eyebrow pencil when you have red or auburn hair can be a challenge.

Let’s face it, most brow products cater to blonde, brunette, and folks with black hair, but redheads need shades that complement their unique hair color and brow hairs too.

Whether you’re a makeup artist looking to stock your kit with a careful selection of pigments or simply searching for the ideal brow product for yourself, I wanted to make it easier for you and give you a great starting point with my pick of the best eyebrow pencils designed with red or auburn hair in mind.



I also wanted to get you looking for the right eyebrow products no matter what shade of red is your own.

Here’s a look at 8 or so top picks that are not only popular but also offer high-quality and long-lasting results.

8 Top Picks for Eyebrow Pencils for Red and Auburn Hair

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in ‘Caramel’

Before I go any further, Brow Wiz is a cult favorite for a reason, and the ‘Caramel’ shade is perfect for those with warm, reddish tones. Its ultra-slim design allows for precise hair-like strokes, making it easy to fill in sparse brows without looking too heavy. The formula is blendable, buildable, and long-lasting, ensuring your brows stay in place all day.

  • Precise tip for detailed application
  • Long-lasting formula
  • Natural, warm reddish-brown shade ideal for light to medium red hair

    Again you know I love the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow products I use them on myself almost every day. And Brow Wiz is basically a foolproof pencil. The built-in spoolie makes it easy to softly blend any overdrawing you may do and it’s just super easy to use, and seems to last forever. And in caramel, you’ll have a warm soft brown shade that will look so pretty and soft but still give you definition.

2. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer in ‘Auburn’

Anastasia Beverly Hills’ Brow Definer in ‘Auburn’ is perfect for those who want a bit more warmth and depth in their brow shade. The unique tapered, triangular tip allows for versatile application—use the thin side for fine strokes or the broader side to fill in larger sparse areas within your brow area. The rich Auburn shade beautifully enhances medium to darker red and auburn tones.

Why it’s popular:

  • Long-lasting and smudge-proof formula
  • Triangular tip for precision and versatility
  • Ideal for medium to deep auburn shades

    Again you know I love the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow products I use them on myself almost every day. And Brow Definer is basically a foolproof pencil.

3. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Powder Duo in ‘Caramel’

If you prefer a softer, more natural brow look, the Anastasia Brow Powder Duo is your best bet for a well-defined brow. And for lighter redheads, the ‘Caramel’ is a game-changer.
Designed specifically if you have strawberry blonde hair or light red hair, this two-tone powder allows you to mix and match shades for a custom color that’s perfectly tailored to your hair tone. It’s easy to apply and build, offering a natural finish.


I love the Brow Powder Duo product from Anastasia BH – it’s compact, the shades are gorgeous, and for personal use, it makes much more sense than investing in a full brow palette (which I love for my kit) but when you dont need 24 different shades at home, you just need one or two, the Brow Powder Duo is a winner eyebrow shadow. And the light soft tones of the Caramel powder are gorgeous for light to medium, warm haired folks.
And if you’re desperate to create an ombre effect then look no further than the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Powder

Why it’s popular:

  • Soft powder finish for a natural look
  • Two shades in one compact for a custom blend
  • Ideal for strawberry blondes or lighter auburn hair

    I also just want to add, I love love love the Brow Powder Duo pots of Anastasia Beverly Hills, so much so that I’ve popped them all together in one convenient palette for work. They give me the added flexibility for being able to cover anyone with any shade of hair and brows to complement, but the blonde and warm tones are perfect whether you work with warmer or ashy blondes the ABH Brow Powder Duos will do the trick. Love em.

4. NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil in ‘Auburn’

A budget-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on quality, the NYX Micro Brow Pencil in ‘Auburn’ is a great choice for both makeup artists and consumers.
It has a fine tip for creating defined, natural-looking brows and the perfect reddish-brown hue for auburn-haired individuals. The formula is smudge-proof and long-wearing, making it an excellent pick for long days or photoshoots.

Why it’s popular:

  • Smudge-proof and long-lasting formula
  • Affordable yet high-quality
  • Precise application for natural results

5. Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil in Warm Auburn

Benefit’s Pencil offers an incredible balance of precision and pigment. The ‘Warm Auburn’ shade is specifically designed to enhance red and auburn hair without leaning too orange.
Its ultra-fine tip allows for accurate, hair-like strokes, while the waterproof formula ensures that your brows stay on point throughout the day, even in humid conditions.

Why it’s popular:

  • Waterproof and long-lasting
  • Ideal warm auburn shade
  • Ultra-fine tip for precision

6. MAC Pro Brow Definer in ‘Genuine Aubergine’

Now indulge me for a minute as I lament in yet another of my old school favorite makeup products that are no longer with us. yeah the old MAC Brow pencil, its gotta be up there with Calorie 2000 mascara for me, but what are you going to do? I guess one blessing in disguise of this travesty is that I discovered this incredible shade in their new Pro Brow Definer range called Genuine Aubergine.

This is like the unicorn of brow pencils for anyone with red tones and even cooler red tones in their hair. And while I hesitate to use the word purple, obviously with a name like aubergine, it definitely falls wihtin the cool tone classification, but on fair skin, on deep skin, this a delicious, gorgeous tone. And for my pro makeup artist friends you might now pull it out to use every single day, you’ll know when you need it.
And I’d almost say that even though this is all about redheads, this aubergine pencil is the perfect shade to be aligned with more neutral cool undertones within the world of redheads.

 This full micro-tip brow pencil is designed specifically for redheads of all kinds, with a soft yet buildable formula that glides on smoothly. The automatic pencil with a micro-fine tip means no sharpening is needed, and its non-greasy, long-wear formula resists humidity and sweat, making it ideal for professional use or all-day wear. And perfect brows day in day out. I love this pencil.

Why it’s popular:

  • Specifically designed for red-hair
  • Smooth application and no sharpening needed
  • Resistant to sweat and humidity

7. L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Definer in ‘Auburn’

Another fantastic drugstore option, the L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Definer in ‘Auburn’ offers excellent quality at a budget-friendly price point. The ultra-fine tip provides precise application, and the auburn shade is perfect for those with red or copper-toned hair. The spoolie brush on the other end helps to blend the product for a natural finish, making this pencil a great everyday option.

Why it’s popular:

  • Affordable and easily accessible
  • Fine tip for detailed application
  • Natural auburn shade for redheads

8. Fenty Beauty in ‘True Red’

Rhianna’s Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil and Styler offers luxury and performance. The ‘Tru Red’ shade is a unique and rich reddish-brown, ideal for those with deeper red or auburn hair. The pencil tip is ultra fine, allowing for faster filling, and has a softer oval shaped paddle brush which makes it easy to correct small mistakes, or over fills – I do this all the time when I totally draw the brow hairlike strokes totally over the lines. And I;ve gotta say, Rhianna’s versatile shades in this range

Why it’s popular:

  • High-quality luxury product
  • Angled tip for quick and precise application
  • Includes a brow highlighter for added definition

Final Brow Furrowers (thoughts…)

When it comes to eyebrow pencils for red or auburn hair, there are plenty of high-quality options that cater to these unique shades, which is refreshing to be able to say. As years ago, I remember this was never the case.

From luxury picks like Fenty to drugstore heroes like NYX, each of these pencils brings something special to the table. Whether you’re a makeup artist looking to stock your kit or a consumer trying to perfect your brow game, these recommendations offer the quality, color match, and performance you need.

I also feel strongly that you don’t need a complex set of brow stencils and brow stamp kit situations to have well-defined brows that complement and work in harmony with your hair color. You simply need the right shade and know the easy steps to apply your pencil with.

Best news is that with the right tool, or pencil, definining your brows should only take maybe 3-5 minutes – no need to take any longer.

And I think this is a comprehensive list that gives you choices of warmth and cool, light and dark and allow you to have the perfect match for whatever complexion and undertone to cross paths with, that has a little fire in their hair.

Click here to listen to this episode!

.

Take Me Back to the Podcast Homepage

More about the Podcast

If you devoured this episode in one bite, subscribe to it. Make it easy for yourself!

And if you have a makeup artist friend who’s just starting out, or you know would love this stuff, share this link with them.
I love makeup and skincare, and it’s my honor to share my passion with you, so you can listen to my weekly show, by simply subscribing below.

.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.